Pago Pago, AMERICAN SAMOA — The House of Representatives has once more declined to confirm Brett Butler to the Board of Directors of the American Samoa Economic Development Authority (ASEDA), marking the second unsuccessful vote on his appointment in just over a year.

In July of last year, Butler’s nomination fell short when only ten representatives voted in support while seven opposed. House rules require eleven votes for confirmation, leaving Butler one vote shy.

A motion for reconsideration, introduced by Rep. Luaitaua Gene Pan, was approved the same day. The reconsideration vote was held Tuesday, but the outcome remained unchanged — this time, with ten votes against confirmation and eight votes in support.

Butler’s nomination has drawn attention largely because of his extensive background in both the private sector and government finance.

He is a veteran executive with more than 30 years of experience in operations and financial management. Butler was the first local General Manager of StarKist Samoa, serving nine years in the Territory’s largest private‑sector employer. He later joined Bumble Bee Foods, rising through several senior leadership roles, including Vice President of Loining Operations, Vice President & General Manager of the Santa Fe Springs branch, and Vice President of Finance Operations.

After returning to American Samoa, Butler served as Executive Advisor for Finance in the Governor’s Office before being appointed Acting Treasurer in September 2025. His tenure included efforts to modernize ASG’s outdated financial systems, strengthen internal controls, and improve fiscal transparency.

During his confirmation hearing for his appointment as Government Treasurer, legislators described him as a model of local leadership returning home to serve the Territory. Senate Budget Chairman Utu Sila Poasa highlighted Butler’s career trajectory as an example of the kind of expertise American Samoa needs in its financial institutions.

He was unanimously approved by the Senate but fell short of confirmation in the House, a pattern that has been repeated in his nomination to ASEDA Board of Directors.

Supporters had described him as a seasoned executive bringing global industry experience back to the Territory. His nomination to ASEDA was seen as aligning with the authority’s mission of overseeing major financing mechanisms for development projects.

The Senate had previously endorsed Butler’s appointment in March of last year with a unanimous 17 – 0 vote, signaling strong support in the upper chamber. However, ASEDA board appointments require concurrence from both chambers, and the House’s repeated rejection effectively blocks Butler from taking the seat.

With the House denying confirmation for a second time, the administration may submit a new nominee for the ASEDA board seat, attempt another reconsideration if procedurally allowed, or withdraw the nomination entirely.

ASEDA plays a central role in financing major infrastructure and development initiatives, making board appointments closely watched within government and business circles.