Serious questions raised about fees and expenses paid out of ASG $10Mil investment
Pago Pago, AMERICAN SAMOA — A financial summary submitted to the Senate Government Operations Investigative Committee by Governor’s Economic Advisor Brett Butler on November 4 has raised serious questions about how American Samoa Government (ASG) funds are being handled under a proposed $100 million financing arrangement.
According to Butler’s report, more than $3 million was taken out of ASG’s $10.1 million airport investment to cover insurance premiums, investment-related fees, escrow attorney costs, and administrative expenses. These deductions were made before ASG had publicly confirmed receiving any of the financing promised under the agreement.
Central in the inquiry is why American Samoa is paying millions of dollars in expenses connected to McKinley, Beech Tree Finance Company, MBT, an escrow attorney, and a surety arrangement when the expected financing has not yet materialized.
The figures in Butler’s November 4 summary show four major deductions:
- $896,000 for an insurance premium.
- $1,162,091 for what is described as “McKinley Associated Fees.”
- $850,000 for escrow attorney fees.
- $100,000 for MBT administrative fees.
Together, these charges amount to $3,008,091, reducing ASG’s original $10.1 million investment to just $7,091,909. This means that nearly one-third of the original investment was already accounted for through fees and expenses before the promised financing was publicly confirmed.
During his November 4 testimony, Butler explained that the insurance policy was intended to protect ASG’s funds while they were held in escrow. He also said a surety arrangement would provide protection after the funds were transferred into a United Arab Emirates (UAE) pension plan.
However, his written summary states that the remaining $7,091,909 would be “disbursed to Surety and UAE.” It does not explain how much would go to the surety, how much would be placed in the UAE pension plan, or whether the surety would receive another payment for its services.
It is also unclear whether any portion of the remaining money would be held as collateral rather than invested on ASG’s behalf.
These details are important because any additional payment to the surety would further reduce the amount of public money available for the investment. In other words, the $7,091,909 may not represent the final amount that would actually be invested for American Samoa.
ASG entered into its agreement with McKinley Investment LLC, committing $10 million for the investment, along with a separate $100,000 application fee.
However, the agreement does not clearly identify or authorize all the additional charges listed in Butler’s November 4 summary. The largest individual charge is the $1,162,091 identified as “McKinley Associated Fees.”
Butler’s summary describes these expenses as relating to “contractual, conversion, MPGA arrangement.” It does not provide a detailed breakdown, identify the individuals or companies that received the money, or explain exactly what services were performed in exchange for the payments.
Another page included in Butler’s document packet lists the name “Meen Eom (MPGA).”
McKinley’s website identifies Eom, also known as Corvin Uhm, as an executive associated with the McKinley group. The website also identifies several companies operating under the MPGA name.
However, Butler’s summary does not specify which MPGA company participated in the transaction, what role it played, or why ASG was responsible for paying these expenses.
Without invoices, payment records, supporting agreements, and a clear explanation of the services provided, it is difficult to determine whether the $1,162,091 was properly charged to ASG or whether some or all of the expenses should have been paid by other parties involved in arranging the financing.
Another major financial issue involves the brokers who helped bring the proposed financing arrangement to American Samoa. Entellus was identified as the broker that introduced the financing proposal to ASG. During his testimony, Butler identified Don Saaga and Agnes Telles as the brokers involved in the transaction and said they reported to Vandana Agrawal.
The agreement separately provides for a 10 percent funding facilitation fee payable to Agrawal after each successful financing installment. However, Butler testified on November 4 that the Entellus brokers would receive $4.5 million.
That amount is particularly significant because it does not appear among the $3,008,091 in deductions already listed in his financial summary. The available information does not establish whether the $4.5 million payment is included in Agrawal’s contractual 10 percent fee or whether it represents an additional commission that would create another expense for the transaction.
If the $4.5 million is separate from the existing deductions, the total cost of arranging the financing could be substantially higher than the amount already reported.
There is also the question of when these brokers are entitled to receive payment. The agreement ties Agrawal’s 10 percent fee to successful financing installments. Yet none of the three promised installments under the $100 million financing package has been publicly confirmed.
ASG therefore needs a clear accounting of the broker compensation arrangement, including who is entitled to payment, how much each person or company will receive, and whether payment is conditional on the successful delivery of financing.
The $850,000 charged for escrow attorney services is another expense that deserves closer examination. According to the information presented, ASG was not a signatory to the escrow agreement. Nevertheless, $850,000 was deducted from its investment to cover the attorney’s fees.
Legal fees associated with a financing transaction are not automatically the responsibility of every participant. There should be a clear contractual basis for charging those expenses to ASG, particularly when the amount involved is $850,000 in public funds.
The government should therefore provide the engagement agreement, invoices, payment records, and any contractual provision used to justify this deduction.
The $896,000 insurance premium also raises questions about who was legally responsible for the expense. The records identify Beech Tree Finance Company, rather than ASG, as the applicant for the guarantee. Generally, the applicant for an insurance guarantee is responsible for paying the premium unless a separate agreement assigns that obligation to another party.
More importantly, ASG’s agreement required McKinley to obtain the insurance. It did not clearly state that ASG would be responsible for paying Beech Tree’s insurance premium. Despite this, the $896,000 was deducted directly from ASG’s investment.
Butler testified that the insurance was intended to protect ASG’s money while it remained in escrow. That explanation addresses the purpose of the insurance, but it does not fully answer the financial question: Why was ASG charged for a policy applied for by another company when its agreement placed the insurance obligation on McKinley?
The government should disclose the insurance policy, the identity of the insured parties and beneficiaries, the premium invoice, and the agreement establishing who was responsible for paying the cost.
It is also important to determine whether ASG is entitled to any refund if the financing arrangement fails to proceed. The final deduction listed in Butler’s summary is a $100,000 administrative fee paid to MBT. However, MBT was not a party to ASG’s agreement with McKinley.
The summary also fails to clarify whether this $100,000 represents the application fee already required under the agreement or an additional administrative charge.
That distinction is important because ASG’s agreement separately required a $100,000 application fee. If the MBT charge is the same fee, the government should identify the payment recipient and explain how the charge was authorized. If it is an additional fee, the government should provide the contractual basis for imposing another $100,000 expense on ASG.
Without this clarification, there is a risk that the government may be paying a fee twice or covering an expense that was never part of its original agreement. Taken together, the deductions raise a broader concern about how the proposed financing arrangement was structured and whose expenses are ultimately being paid with American Samoa's money.
SUMMARY
ASG committed $10.1 million to a transaction intended to help secure $100 million in financing. Yet Butler’s November 4 summary shows that $3,008,091 was allocated to various fees and expenses before any of the three promised financing installments had been publicly confirmed.
The result is that ASG is left with $7,091,909 from its original investment, even before determining whether another payment must be made to the surety.
This creates a serious financial concern. The government entered the arrangement expecting to obtain $100 million in financing, but a substantial portion of its own investment has already been consumed by costs associated with other companies and individuals involved in putting the transaction together.
The most troubling aspect of this transaction is not simply that more than $3 million has been deducted from ASG’s investment. It is that the available records do not clearly explain why these expenses were charged to the government, who ultimately received the money, or what contractual authority supports each payment.
ASG's original $10.1 million commitment has already been reduced to $7,091,909 on paper. That amount could fall even further if the surety arrangement requires additional payments.
Meanwhile, none of the three promised financing installments under the $100 million package have been publicly confirmed as received.

