Tsunami scientist presents findings of Sept. 29 wave
By Tina Mata’afa tina@samoanews.com

 Font | Size: 

Acknowledging the earthquake as the warning, long-term planning and education are key factors the territory must consider in order to lessen the local tsunami risk, says Dr. Guy Gelfenbaum, an oceanographer with the U.S. Geological Survey.

In presenting the findings of several groups of scientists who were in American Samoa to study the Sept. 29 tsunami’s impact, Gelfenbaum closed his presentation with this: “there is no easy solution to the local tsunami risk.”

“The earthquake is the warning. Long-term planning is essential. Education is the tool,” reads one of his final slides. “Individuals must know what to do.”

More than 100 people — college students, members of the academic community and concerned citizens — attended the presentation held at the American Samoa Community College Lecture Hall, Thursday, Oct. 22.

To reduce losses in future tsunamis, Gelfenbaum says tsunami education programs must be promoted. In addition, he urges “keep the memory of the Sept. 29 catastrophe”. The tsunami killed more than 100 people in Samoa, American Samoa and Tonga.

SCIENTIFIC STUDY

The goals of the tsunami study were to:

— Measure tsunami wave heights, run-up and inundation distances;

— Understand magnitude and pattern of inundation; and

— Improve models of tsunami inundation to help prepare against future tsunami hazards.

In order to accomplish these goals, scientists took eyewitness accounts from villagers, measured water levels at the beach, inland and run ups; flow directions; inundation distance; topographic profiles, sediment deposits; subsidence and coastal change.

Some traces that indicate how high the wave got include dead plants, debris and broken tree branches.

He said in studying tsunamis, timing is key as scientists must collect data quickly. In speaking with witnesses, they found that there was minor structural damage due to the earthquake and that the tsunami arrived between 15-20 minutes after the earthquake. The second wave was the largest.

Understanding the tsunami impact, said Gelefenbaum, is important for hazard mitigation in order to prepare for future incidents. Pointing to two sites, he said in Tula, in northeastern Tutuila, homes were destroyed and floods were about waist high because Tula is a low lying coastal plain. He said scientists found something like they had never seen elsewhere — clumps of land thrown onto the land by the wave.

In Poloa, which was completely wiped out save for one home and a church, Gelefenbaum said the wave was high and had a lot of force, the height of the wave in Poloa about 30-35 feet.

As reported previously in the Samoa News, the tsunami hit at 6:48 a.m. in the Samoa Islands Region, off the Tongan Trench. Gelfenbaum said Thursday the Sept. 29 tremor occurred at the subduction zone where the Pacific Plate is sliding, or, converging under the Australia Plate, the plates moving into each other 1.5 inches every year.

“This is quite fast,” he said. “The Pacific Plate is sliding under the Australia Plate. Stresses build up and the release of stresses causes a large earthquake.”

He said the Samoa Islands Region is a complicated region that has lots of earthquakes, 12 in the last 100 years. There have been a number of relatively large earthquakes in the past, the largest before the Sept. 29 tremblor taking place June 17, 1917 —an 8.5 magnitude earthquake which generated a tsunami that destroyed homes and a church in Pago Pago Harbor. Run up, or the height of the tsunami was 4 ft.

A tsunami forms when an earthquake vertically displaces the seafloor and the water above it and tsunami waves differ from wind waves, Gelfenbaum continued, noting that the wavelength of a tsunami decreases in shallow water while its height increases in shallow water.

“When the wave gets to shore it responds differently...it doesn’t just wash up and wash out,” he said. “A tsunami wave keeps flowing on shore, it moves like a fast rising tide.”

The earthquake of Sept. 29, that registered 8.0-8.3 on the Richter scale, Gelfenbaum said, resulted in a tsunami that “traveled all across the Pacific Ocean” to the west coast U.S. But he added the further the wave travels, its height dissipates.

In their studies, scientists found that witnesses saw an initial drawdown (water receding), and villagers counted differing numbers of waves. Some villagers told Samoa News they saw between three to five waves and others say there were up to seven. Scientists determined that were three large waves in Samoa’s Sept. 29 tsunami, each coming in about 12 minutes apart.

In the vicinity of village channels (auvai), they found higher run up as though the channels fueled the tsunami. In their model, scientists found that even with different reef widths, run ups were about the same.

In his conclusion, Gelfenbaum says tsunami education programs must be promoted and that the memory of Sept. 29 should be kept alive.

“People on both sides of the island had training last year and they knew what to do after the earthquake...in Tula...they had training one or two weeks before the tsunami...it helps to know what to do,” he said. “Finding ways of keeping the memory of the event so information is passed down. There might be a tsunami in a week or in a hundred years...people need to be prepared.”

Reconstruction he says must be planned so that routes and paths easily lead people to safe areas. He says critical structures such as schools and hospitals should be built out of inundation zones.

“As government plans reconstruction, if you’re going to have to rebuild and it is possible to do so, don’t locate them in inundation zones,” he said. “There is not much time...it’s only a few minutes...individuals need to know what to do...there won’t be any time for governments to warn people.”

Advertisement
Comments to this story (7)
Tama Samoa Moni  wrote:
26 Oct 2009 01:39 PM
Great stuff, I suggest it be translated in to simple Samoan language and distribute to all villages. Have sessions in schools and distribute this material to our kids. Have ASG start looking at a feasibility study to construct or built some "higher ground access area" for those villages on the beach areas, so that they have a "higher ground place" to run/walk up to when tsunamis are looming. Another suggestion is for ASG to look at possibility of linking the ridge up in Pago/Fagasa pass and Aasu/Aoloau area and built a road there. Someone said that there was actually a road that the CB's built during the 2nd World War from the Fagasa pass in to the Malaeimi overpass area. Maybe we can retrace those areas and start having roads up in the mountains to cross over. My main reason for the road up at Pago/Fagasa & A'asu/Aoloau area is to enable us to link to Fagaalu in case the whole road area from Nuuli to Fagaalu is washed away. We need to have access to the hospital at all times. Something similar shoud be done about linking the east area to the hospital. Think about it, am sure a lot of people out there also have some better ideas.
yah  wrote:
26 Oct 2009 12:05 PM

This is purely scientific research...people "should not" mix these scientists findings with their religious beliefs...however if you decided to do so, then fine but do not attempt to interpret the september 29 event with your personal religious beliefs against science...if that is what you believe then fine but science cannot be disproved or approved by religion because it's two separate things.

Purple Heart Recipient"Noble Cause" Vietnam War>  wrote:
26 Oct 2009 06:25 AM
Regardless of what the scientist predicted from their study, will be hopeless, because people suppose to follow the teaching of the gospel of Jesus Christ and become the doer and endurer of his word as we learn. And if we only serve him from our lips, he will condemn those who does it, and his wrath will continue come upon the earth for the disobedisnce, and harden of hearts unto him. What people ought to know is that God is Love....also he is the vengence toward our disobedience, and the harden of our hearts toward his commendment. Therefore the scientist got their knowledge from God and that doesn't means they're always right. It all depend upon how we serve him by keeping his commandment, he said. I am not saying this showing I am perfect, no study and reseach on my own what the gospel of Jesus Christ really meant to me. I can't wait for anyone to make a change in my life, has to be me make those changing. And if I cannot do follow him, and try to keep his commandment, I will fall into terrestrial world, and not celestial world. The celestial world will help us commune with thee, and he will keep us safe in his arms.
Johana Loreene Cramer  wrote:
25 Oct 2009 07:21 AM
The village Amanave id totally destroyed by the tsunami
Sam O.  wrote:
25 Oct 2009 07:02 AM
This is exactly what I've been saying needs to happen in schools. Kids needs tsunami drills and education. The government also needs to start some public education programs. I can't believe how many people continued on with their daily routine after such a massive quake. I also can't believe how many people didn't know that a receding water line straight after a big quake meant a tsunami was coming. I can't help but wonder how many lives could have been saved had more people known to expect a tsunami after a huge quake and to head for high ground immediately. At least the whole island knows now...
TB  wrote:
24 Oct 2009 06:04 PM
Great info to hand out to the public especially to villages near the beach. It will be great if all villages have an emergency walking track up the hill when things like this happen, ppl would know where to go and creat less panic situation. Its common sense instead of waiting for someone else to hold your hand all the time. Chiefs and Matais should look into it and start planning with the help from the experts you're be doing it in your sleep.just a suggestion.
Joe Weilenman, FAIA  wrote:
24 Oct 2009 07:53 AM
How can I get copies of the technical data developed by the tsunami study team? Joe Weilenman, FAIA, Architect jnwarch@blueskynet.as